We just had our first Supper Club experience last week on The Miracle. It was nothing less than INCREDIBLE!
The dress code seems to follow along with the standard dining room code: Cruise elegant on the classier nights and a little less on the relaxed nights. We were escorted to our table and had 2 servers taking care of our every whim for the 2.5 hours we were there. As soon as we ordered they brought us "complimentary samples" from the chef. My husband has a cold tomato soup and I had a tuna tartare. It was just enough to tease the appetite. We were offered bread numerous times and they selected 3 accompaniments for the bread...butter, tomato bruscetta and an olive spread. We ordered lobster bisque...decedent! Our appetizers were presented with flair and finese. Our Caesar Salad was made tableside, traditionally. Our entrees were done TO PERFECTION and dessert was just the right size to enjoy but not push us over the edge. We did not order the potato/side dish; we decided the extra starch was not needed! Our drinks were refilled just as soon as they disappeared and what struck us as the epitome of politeness was the servers did NOTHING without asking permission first! "May I take your plate"? "May I present your bill now?". We were not rushed nor were we made to feel anything but welcomed and wanted for those 2.5 hours.
To answer the question of ordering more than one of something...I do not know if you can or even if you should. There will be more than enough served to you as standard fare. I do feel confident in telling you the staff is SO ACCOMMODATING...if you ask, I am sure they will do whatever they can to make your dining an event to remember.
The bill was $30 a person and there is a slot for tipping. The experience is worth about 10 times what the charge is. When you have this dining adventure, you will remember every moment and cherish each bite!!!