We decided to splurge because we were afraid that a cabin issue might sour us on the cruising experience. But it was a hard decision. I found it really difficult to wade through all the category levels and try to put a relative value on each vs. the actual cost. Doesn't help when the costs can change dramatically over a couple of days. Oh well.
I found a great review blog of Liberty c/w lots of pix. Young couple travelling with her parents. First time for the youngers, with olders being experienced cruisers. Was the Western Caribbean cruise, but I just skipped over their ports of call. No kids so no info on their programming but...
http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=989561&highlight=libertyOn a personal note I want to tell you how much I and my wife Sandra appreciated and enjoyed your posts. I can tell you and your family are as excited as Sandra and I are (and the kid if she knew about it).