Unfortunately, folks are not big into reading the fine print when they are on vacation.
And Carnival's reputation took a hit with this one. That is why I am glad Carnival closed it down.
As for thinking that Carnival ran it, there are many things that are on Carnival ships that Carnival does not own or run. The Spa for one. The gift shop for another. Both are subcontracted out to other companies. The Art Auction for another. So it is not uncommon for someone else to sell their "wares" on a Carnival ship.
Hubby- 9 Carnival Cruises starting in 1982.
Plus Family of Four since 1998 -
32 Carnival cruises.
Ships sailed: (some multiple times)
Mardi Gras, Festivale, Tropicale, Jubilee, Holiday, Celebration, Fantasy, Inspiration, Sensation, Paradise, Imagination, Fascination, Spirit, Legend, Pride, Miracle, Victory, Conquest.,Ecstasy, Splendor, Freedom, Glory, Valor
Booked for 2009 :
Dream December 3, 2009 (Spa Cabin)
Triumph December 31, 2009
Fantasy May 8, 2010