Hi!! When i first started cruising in my teens, i did have an oceanview and in MY opinion, there is no question on the differance...The Balcony is the way to go!! There are other times of the day you will use that area besides breakfast..like taking a break from your traveling companion, watching the sunrise/sunsets from your own private area is definately one of life's most peaceful, soul enhancing experiences. You will find you feel a little more connected to the other passengers who witness the same beautiful scenery out there. That Spa $$$, you can always do the port day discount if you feel you really need it, and that way you can have the best of both worlds...your balcony AND the Spa!! I AM SOLD ON THE BALCONY, AND WOULD CHANGE MY VACATION DATES FOR ONE!!! I hope i helped ya out!!..I'll be on mine on the Freedom on 2/22/09!!!! WHOO HOOO!!!!!!!!! Happy Cruising and Happy Planning!!!!!!!!