Hello, I just returned yesterday from the Western Caribbean tour on the Legend. Do you snorkel much? I have...in Hawaii and in San Diego too. Snorkeling in the Caribbean was terribly disappointing (Grand Cayman, Cozumel, Belize, Roatan) Roatan was "good" snorkeling but nothing compared to Hawaii. Much of the coral is dead. So, very very few fish. If you've never snorkeled before, it's fun but you won't know what you're missing. Hawaii was fabulous in the 90s. Just go back. Also, do NOT take the Atlantis. Expensive - 99$ and nothing to see. COmplete waste of money and time.
Linda